Camosun Story #66: Dianne

Dianne is a faculty member in the Healthcare Assistant (HCA) program, and she was a recipient of a Camosun College Teacher Recognition Award this past spring.

Dianne has been at Camosun since 2003; in fact, she retired for a spell (and was retired during the COVID pivot) and came back because she loves teaching.  “My teaching actually goes back to a one-room public school in rural Manitoba where I invigilated exams and helped teach the little ones.  My mom and grandmother were both teachers, as is my daughter.” While Dianne doesn’t have formal teacher training (she has a Bachelor of Nursing and a Bachelor of Management in Human Resources) as she told me, “a nurse is always a teacher because you have to teach patients, students, residents, and other health care staff.”  Dianne has been a registered nurse in Australia, Manitoba, Alberta, and in British Columbia since 1989 where she was employed initially in occupational health and safety with Juan de Fuca hospitals and BC Ferries.  “I’ve had a varied career for sure, working particularly with seniors and persons with dementia since 2000.” Since 2003, when she came to Camosun, Dianne has been teaching in the Healthcare Assistant program, which has grown from two intakes a year to many more when the Health Care Access Program (HCAP) began.

Dianne reflected on the changes in the student demographics over the years.  “Today we have many more international and ESL students who come in with a lot of knowledge and varied backgrounds. I have a student right now who has a Master’s in Social Work from South Asia and I have three RN students from other countries. The diversity is phenomenal.”  Dianne also notes that many of today’s students struggle with mental health issues and learning challenges.  “More of our students are being supported by the Centre for Accessible Learning (CAL) than in previous years, but the HCA program is a great place to start, as it really is the basic beginning in healthcare education.”

I asked Dianne what keeps her coming back to teaching. “What I like most is helping students learn how to learn and gain confidence in themselves. Those students who already know how to learn don’t really need me, but so many students have been beaten down by the system, so, to me it’s about building their self-esteem.  I am inspired when students who have struggled with education in the past get an A and take a picture to send to their mom, even though they are 45 years old!” Some students have not been in school for 20 to 30 years and these are the students Dianne especially enjoys mentoring. It seems to take longer to get some students to focus in class and I watch for students having difficulty with attendance.”

But what Dianne emphasized to me was her thinking around assignments and exams. “My personal philosophy is that an assignment is a measure of how effective your teaching was as you go through the material, in other words, assignments are tools for teaching not tools of evaluation, whereas exams are evaluative. Students hear only about 20%of the content presented by the instructor in class. I am not surprised that many students are unsure of what the assignment is asking when they first start the program. We fail as teachers if students don’t learn how to learn, so I spend a lot of time going over what’s expected of an assignment, making sure students understand what’s needed, referring them to the writing center, even looking at drafts before they submit them especially for students who have been away from studies as long time or for ESL students who want clarification on English wording. I don’t punish students for late assignments but try to get to know my students as well as I can so I can address their specific learning needs. The curriculum can be very difficult for some students.”

Dianne also finds that her own experiences coming back to teach post-COVID have been challenging, due to the increased use of technology to support teaching and learning.  “It’s been very difficult, and it used to bother me terribly because I felt incompetent, but I’ve tried to put that away because I’m a nurse, not a computer technician.” But when the technology challenges affect the students, Dianne becomes very frustrated.  “Students find writing exams stressful at the best of times and we shouldn’t be adding to this stress because our technology is not working.”

One of the Dianne’s thoughts resonated with me because other faculty member have mentioned it as well: that students should have a course built into all curriculum to help them learn the technologies and other skills they need to succeed at the college.  “I think we need to step back from the academics during a student’s first week because they’re too anxious and overwhelmed to really learn much of the content. We need to give them practical hands-on skills. We need to build in more resources to help students be successful. Teaching is not just about covering content. It’s helping students learn how to learn, learn how to find things, and learn who’s there to help them. I would like to see a more supportive approach at Camosun with more integration of support services throughout the term and the program, not just on the first day. In the first three weeks of my classes, I build in how to study, how to read a textbook, how to highlight, how to make notes. And then I offer extra after-class time with students who need it.”

I asked Dianne about some of the memories that stood out for her over her many years of teaching, and one story she had for me was amazing.  “I had a young woman who had to travel a long distance to get to her clinical sessions. Clinical started at seven and one day she got there right at seven with her coat on and was having trouble concentrating that morning. I went to talk to her later about being almost late and she said that on her way to clinical, she had come across an accident, so she stopped and found the driver was not breathing. She was by herself, so did CPR, and when somebody else came along he called 911 (she didn’t have a cellphone). She saved the driver’s life.”  A good reminder to remember to have empathy for our students before jumping to conclusions about their behaviour.

My final question for Dianne was around what advice she would give new faculty coming in to teach in her program.  And not surprisingly, she recommends new faculty get more help with technology, but also to “use the resources other people have already built for their courses and customize them, because this can be a good way to learn the material yourself.”  Dianne also thinks new faculty should critically review the way existing assignments and exams are worded and “have the confidence to point out when they don’t make sense to them. Because of time constraints, we often repeat and reuse our content and assessments without fine-tuning, but new faculty see them with fresh eyes.”

In addition, Dianne wants new faculty to be better supported.  “New faculty often come on term contracts.  They get lost in the system and try to cope without a lot of support. I think sometimes we as an organization are so busy with bureaucracy and budgets, we lose sight of the people who are supporting our students, the people who are in the front of the classroom keeping the students in our programs.”  Without faculty and students (and people to support them), our institution is just a building – it’s time for us to refocus on what really matters.

What are They Seeing When They See Me? A reflection from Robin Fast, Education Developer, CETL

Last spring, Camosun College Centre for Excellence in Teaching and Learning (CETL) Book Club participants read Picture a Professor: Interrupting Biases about Faculty and Increasing Student Learning.

If you’re anything like me, you spend time wondering how you are coming across to the students in your class. Do I sound competent? Do I look competent? What are they deciding about me as they enter my class for the first time and what impact will those decisions have on their ability to engage in the learning process? Does dressing casually help them relax or tell them I can’t be taken seriously? Is my age – too young or too old – colouring their perceptions before we even begin to work together?

I could share more of these questions but I’m already tiring myself with my own angst.

Thankfully, Picture a Professor explores this challenge, focusing specifically on the experiences of faculty who do not meet the societal expectations of what a professor should be. The authors examine the stereotypes that follow teachers into the classroom; unpack how these biases can impact teachers, students, and the learning process; and offer practical strategies, both at the classroom and institutional level, for disrupting biases and supporting a diverse academy and engaged pedagogy.

According to the text, we often fail to acknowledge that identity matters. We ignore the impact our bodies, and biases about our bodies, have on the teaching and learning process and, as a result, conversations about effective teaching and learning practice are incomplete. The authors point out that “White women, women faculty of colour, faculty with physical disabilities,, non-binary faculty, and all Black, Indigenous, and people of Colour faculty must navigate different intersectional mazes of racial, gender, and other biases about embodied identity on an exhausting daily basis.”

Picture a Professor is divided into four sections with authors telling their stories and offering strategies on managing the first day of class, building trust and rapport with students, increasing equity through anti-racist pedagogies, and the value of teaching with our whole selves.

According to Jassamyn Neuhaus, the book’s editor, while each author writes from their own experience and describe strategies that align with their own context, several principles emerge that can be widely applied. First, the authors consistently engage in ongoing learning and reflection. “They try new things, assess, reflect on what worked and what didn’t, revise, and try again.” Second, the authors don’t “go it alone,” but instead study the existing research to “help them understand their own experiences and to develop teaching strategies.” They “find their people” and engage in conversations about teaching and learning with others in similar situations. And finally, the authors reimagine the role of the professor in the teaching and learning process. They share power in the classroom, create authentic learning experiences, and build strong, supportive classrooms, viewing themselves as part of the learning community they are building.

Picture a Professor led to deep discussions for the Book Club. We shared our own biases about what a professor should be and examined how we fit or didn’t fit those images. We considered our places of privilege and how that influenced our work. We talked about the characteristics we hold and what influence they might have on the perception students have of our abilities. We shared our first-day strategies and talked about what we might change or add for the next semester that would help students get to know us, help them examine and manage their perceptions and expectations, and help to build a more effective learning community. We talked about how bringing more of ourselves to our teaching, through stories and other strategies, could strengthen our relationships with students and their engagement with our courses and with their own learning journey. We considered the vulnerability that many faculty experience because of the biases held by students and colleagues and discussed how we could implement the tools shared in the text to disrupt these biases.

If you are interested in exploring these ideas, Picture a Professor is a wonderfully thought provoking resource.

Additional resources can be found with any of us at CETL and:

Camosun’s LibGuide: Equity, diversity, and inclusion

Camosun’s LibGuide: Dismantling racism & oppression